Friday, April 25, 2008

We Were Warned

All I hear about these days is the housing crisis and the resulting recession. I can only listen to this for so long before I have to speak up. The fact is that we were warned about this long ago. Not by Alan Greenspan or any number of top economists today. No, I’m talking 130 years ago, when an economist named Henry George wrote his magnum opus, Progress and Poverty. In it, he explained the crucial and underappreciated role that land plays in the economy. In a time when we have such a serious housing crisis, it would serve us to take heed.

So what is this land connection? To understand that, we must first understand what in economics is known as rent. This may prove somewhat difficult, as the economic definition is different from the way we commonly use the term. The difficulty is further compounded by the fact that neoclassical economists have expanded the meaning of the term from what it originally meant(largely in an attempt to obscure Henry George's ideas). As it was originally understood, rent meant the economic return of land to the landowner, just as wages were the return of labor, and interest the return of capital. What is unique about rent is that it requires no effort on the part of the landowner to increase in value, but rather is determined by activity of society as a whole. We all understand this, which is why homeownership is considered such a good investment. If a new park is built nearby, the land value goes up. If a new grocery store opens nearby, the land value goes up. Of course, if there is an increase in crime or pollution, the land value goes down. In fact, land value is a great economic indicator of just how prosperous and well-functioning a particular area is. Any money the government spends on public works mysteriously ends up in land values.